New Directions
About: What direction will the evolution of cities take us? Options vary greatly! Large cities may be turning into networks of citified villages. A catastrophe could lead us to rebuilding cities (and our civilization) into new ways of living, even a return to the distant past. Or, we could develop our cities today in ways that make them more human and healthier. (Photo credit: Adrian Schwarz, Unsplash)
If you joined here, check out Part 1: Are cities key to human survival.
______________________________________________________
A citified world of villages
Cities may transform into villages large or small, but significantly smaller than cities. People know each other, they work together and play together. Kids go to the same school as their neighbors. A closely-knit village has a family-like feeling. It is sometimes hard for new-comers to integrate, especially if they come from other countries.
A risk: Will establishing closely-knit villages evolve into segregated communities of only people who are like each other, ethnically, religiously or politically?
A world-wide network of small collections of people living like in villages is a tempting vision, but raises the question of how would we manage the production and services provided today by global companies and multinationals on scales we ignore. Or do we not need these services? What alternatives do we have?
The 15-minute city
Like in a village or small town, the 15-minute city means you can walk to anywhere in 15 minutes. This includes school for kids and shopping and community events, and access to healthcare. You come into contact with other people every time you go out! The term comes from Carlos Moreno, an urbanist who worked with the mayor of Paris, Anne Hidalgo, in 2020.
A simpler, non-urban world with new rules for survival
Simplicity in Earth Abides
In Earth Abides, written by George R. Stewart in 1949, there is a global-wide fall of civilization from a deadly disease and the birth. A new culture develops with simpler tools and where highly skilled specialists will not survive. The novel reverses our thinking about how to survive if civilization is rebooted.
In the novel, a Isherwood Williams, a survivor of the earlier world leads us to discover new concepts of family, education and even civilization. The characters are well-developed, especially the children who have easily adapted to the new world of simpler tools and survival skills all of which which became a game, underlying which are superstitions that Isherwood cannot overcome.
Read more about Earth Abides and how civilization is reborn
The title comes from Ecclesiastes 1.4: “Men go and come, but Earth abides”. To abide means to endure, wait patiently, remain in place. That’s what the earth does with or without us.
The main character is Isherwood Williams, a survivor of the plague because he was bitten by a rattlesnake in a cave and had immunity. He returns from the cave and finds everyone dead.
Themes of the book include leadership, beliefs, law and order, societal norms when all sense of community is gone. In fact there is , nothing but a small tribe; of which he becomes the de facto leader.
Thoughts from the novel:
What is change? “(Isherwood) had thought of change itself—how sometimes it comes from the inside of a man, reacting outward against the environment, and how sometimes the environment presses in against the man, forcing him to change. Only the unusual man perhaps was strong enough to press outward against the world.”
What is civilization? The book covers three post-plague generations. Civilization depends on memory, memories of a lot of people. A small number of survivors is not sufficient. Civilization needs to start again.
What is family? “(Isherwood) thought the family was the toughest of all human institutions. It had preceded civilization, and so it naturally survived afterwards.”
Where does superstition come from? “Twenty-two years later, the community flourishes, with the younger generation adapting easily to the more traditional world. They come to have a better grasp of the natural world than the adults, and when running water fails, the younger generation comes to the rescue, knowing where flowing streams may be found. Ish turns his attention from ecology to his newly forming society, and he notices that the children are becoming very superstitious. One day Ish asks for his hammer which he habitually carries around, and finds the children are afraid to touch it as it is a symbol to them of the old times; the long-dead “Americans” of the old world are now viewed like gods, including Ish.”
Please read Earth Abides. You won’t forget many scenes, written over 70 years ago, that reflect our present-day emotions and concerns.
Survival in World War Z: An Oral History of the Zombie War
Along the same idea of a simpler world, we have World War Z: An Oral History of the Zombie War by Max Brooks where a zombies plague has affected the world, destroying much of the way people live. The idea of zombies seems far-fetched, but as you get into the book, the obstacles, actions and results of people around the world fighting or protecting themselves from the zombies takes on a present-future time feeling.
Among the strong ideas in the book, we must avoid suicidal ignorance that comes from not knowing the basic survival skills. The section about life in the US after the zombies reverses common ideas about work. As people had to find ways to survive, many office workers discovered the emotional satisfaction of doing physical labor. The skills of newly-arrived immigrants were highly valued. In job retraining programs they were the instructors because they knew how to live with very little and improvise with what they had.
The book, taking us around the world, is a massive accomplishment and deals with fears and uncertainties in realistic ways we can easily imagine living today.
Read more about World War Z and how people survived
“We needed to get a lot of white collars dirty”.
A few extracts to give you a feeling:
“A great many of our instructors were first-generation immigrants. These were the people who knew how to take care of themselves, how to survive on very little and work with what they had. These were the people who tended small gardens in their backyards, who repaired their own homes, who kept their appliances running for as long as mechanically possible. It was crucial that these people teach the rest of us to break from our comfortable, disposable consumer lifestyle even though their labor had allowed us to maintain that lifestyle in the first place.”
…
“I met one gentleman on a coastal ferry from Portland to Seattle. He had worked in the licensing department for an advertising agency, specifically in charge of procuring the rights to classic rock songs for television commercials. Now he was a chimney sweep. Given that most homes in Seattle had lost their central heat and the winters were now longer and colder, he was seldom idle. “I help keep my neighbors warm,” he said proudly. I know it sounds a little too Norman Rockwell, but I hear stories like that all the time. “You see those shoes, I made them,” “That sweater, that’s my sheep’s wool,” “Like the corn? My garden.” That was the upshot of a more localized system. It gave people the opportunity to see the fruits of their labor, it gave them a sense of individual pride to know they were making a clear, concrete contribution to victory, and it gave me a wonderful feeling that I was part of that. I needed that feeling. It kept me sane for the other part of my job. So much for “talent.” “Tools” are the weapons of war, and the industrial and logistical means by which those weapons are constructed.”
…
“(It was) crucial that these people teach the rest of us to break from our comfortable, disposable consumer lifestyle even though their labor had allowed us to maintain that lifestyle in the first place.
The more work you do , the more money you make, the more peons you hire to free you up to make more money. And suddenly that peon is your teacher , maybe even your boss . For some, this was scarier than the living dead.”
World War Z (p. 138-139).
Today, as we enter summers of extreme heat, potential lack of electrical energy, increase in seal levels, people migrating to higher lands, we need to learn new ways of taking care of ourselves. Ask yourself how many survival skills do you have? If you end up outside your home in a natural environment, or if large groups of people force their way into your property to escape floods or fires, what can you do? Do you know how to build a fire? Navigate by a compass? Find and purify water? Make a meal from the herbs and plants around you? This may sound outlandish, but it is not impossible.
New urbanism
Walkability first
New urbanism is based on characteristics of cities in the past that were lost when urban sprawl and the automobile culture took over.
The concept of walkability is a key underlying goal especially in high density and crowded areas.
New Urbanism is in fact based on principles from the past, how cities have been built for centuries. People can talk, housing, shopping and public spaces are close together. The movement was created in the early 1980’s and in 1993 the key people founded the Congress for the New Urbanism.
Read more about New Urbanism
Human-scaled design: “Our mission is to champion walkable urbanism.”
New Urbanism is a movement created in the early 1980s, by architect Peter Calthorpe, along with Andrés Duany, Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk, and others. You can see their profiles here (https://www.cnu.org/who-we-are/board-of-directors). Calthorpe, Duany, Moule, Plater-Zyberk, Polyzoides, and Solomon founded the Chicago-based Congress for the New Urbanism in 1993. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Urbanism The article has a very interesting section on “Defining elements”)
https://www.cnu.org/resources/what-new-urbanism
“CNU’s mission is to champion walkable urbanism. We provide resources, education, and technical assistance to create socially just, economically robust, environmentally resilient, and people centered places. We leverage New Urbanism’s unique integration of design and social principles to advance three key goals: to diversify neighborhoods, to design for climate change, and to legalize walkable places.” https://www.cnu.org/who-we-are/organization
The charter goes into more detail about what this means practically. https://www.cnu.org/who-we-are/charter-new-urbanism
There are many examples described on Public Square. https://www.cnu.org/publicsquare/author/robert-steuteville
New Urbanism is not without critics, some very strong. It has been accused of practicing social engineering, limiting free enterprise, centrally planned.
However, I believe the philosophy and practices of New Urbanism will continue to spread. There are multiple other movements around the world that work in the spirit of New Urbanism. The Wikipedia has a long list by location with details.
For me, the conclusion is that the energy created by New Urbanism is so strong that its impact will only increase, making urban life more livable.
Urban farming
More people in cities means fewer in the countryside, growing food. In addition, expansion of cities takes up land that was previously used for farming.
There will be fewer people in the country to grow and produce food and land that was previously agricultural will be replaced by housing, suburbs and roadways. Going to the local market to get fruit and vegetables will no longer be possible for most people, although in some large cities, Los Angeles for example, there are now quite a few local food markets. This evolution back to a village-like past, a sign that pure urban living is becoming more human.
Another sign is the rise of urban farming. Urban farming has pros and cons.
Urban farming can increase food security and help alleviate poverty. Urban farming can also help make cities greener. Urban farmers need to know and respect the guidelines for how pesticides and herbicides are used. Assuming there are agricultural standards for safe consumption, urban farming is part of a solution as it reduces the artificial barrier between rural and cities, between countryside and urban living. Some feel it returns agriculture to where it started: in cities where people lived.
Read more about urban farming
Success in urban farming led to risk with the rise of gentrification in cities. Vertical farming may be the answer for cities.
Urban farming has been so successful in many places because it brings options for people in urban areas to find fresh fruit and vegetables and other locally-produced products.
Local governments often designate land in lower-income areas for urban farming. Middle class people are attracted to the image of city farming, and move in to displace the original occupants who are then pushed further from the city.
Something similar to this happened in Washington DC when a middle-class urban farming project was placed among public-housing units in low-income areas. Montreal had a similar as did Scotland. Issues were lack of local support, integration with other initiatives, lack of knowledge and skills on the part of the “urban farmers”. The Risks of Urban Agriculture, published by McGill Policy Association is a good overview or the challenges.
They cite a successful initiative that started in Singapore and is based on vertical farming technology. The company is Sky Greens, and their mission:
- To constantly provide improved agricultural solutions with minimal impact on land, water and energy resources through invention and innovation
- To help cities actualise food supply security and food safety targets
- To promote and enable seamless integration of low carbon footprint agriculture into urban living
Cities designed for medical wellness
Another risk that has come to our attention thanks to the Covid pandemic is the forced physical proximity in cities. Simply taking public transportation puts people face-to-face body-to-body in subways and buses during rush hours. As we learned belatedly during the Covid pandemic, people need to keep their distances.
Cities are crowded places with people too close together making it easy for viruses to spread.
How can cities be designed to keep people further apart, to prevent diseases from spreading? Geoff Manaugh in his well-known blog dedicated to architecture and design, BLDGBLOG, suggests that infectious diseases and sanitation problems can arise as people in cities come into close contact with other people who are ill, or have contracted a contagious disease. In this 2009 blog post Managaugh gives examples of swine flu and how it was a result of people living to close to animals. “Swine flu, we could say, is a spatial problem – an epiphenomenon of landscape.”
He links to the Salon del Mobile where in 2010 , over 10 years ago, the CDC released a new line of furniture designed to keep people from sitting too close together.
To borrow his words, how can we ensure that ”the modern city would thus not only be a place to live – it would also be a functioning medical instrument.”
The long Manaugh article shares examples of how people have tried or are trying to do this. It is well worth a thoughtful read.
He finishes with this:
“In 50 years will you be walking around the edges of the city with your grandkids when one of them asks: Why are these buildings out here, so far away from the rest?
“And you’ll say: They’re here because of swine flu. We redesigned the city and our diseases went away.”
References
Explore a selection of resources about books and themes covered in this post
Earth Abides
Earth Abides, written by George R. Stewart in 1949. It has been in continuous print (and twenty languages) since 1949. In 1951 it won the International Fantasy Award.
Read this only if you do not intend to read the book. Detailed descriptions are spoilers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_Abides …and more….
The life and works of George R. Stewart, http://georgerstewart.com/
http://georgerstewart.com/earthabides.html
The solo piano composition Earth Abides https://www.sweetgrassmusic.com/product/earth-abides-for-solo-piano/
World War Z: An Oral History of the Zombie War
This book is so well known, you can find many links to reviews and comments on the internet. Specify “book” when you do a search because the movie, video games and other spinoffs are plentiful.
Full description with spoilers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_Z
An excerpt: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.ca/books/18957/world-war-z-by-max-brooks/9780307346612/excerpt
New Urbanism
The reference site: CNU Congress for the New Urbanism https://www.cnu.org/resources
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Urbanism The article has a very interesting section on “Defining elements”
Urban farming
The Risks of Urban Agriculture, published by McGill Policy Association – https://mcgillpolicyassociation.com/latest-articles/2019/11/8/the-risks-of-urban-agriculture
Sky Greens, in Singapore https://www.skygreens.com/about-skygreens/
BLDGBLOG
BLDGBLOG, “building blog” by Geoff Manaugh https://bldgblog.com/
Architecture and the built environment through a lens of technology, literature, crime, history, archaeology, acoustics, science fiction, subterranean space, warfare, the planetary sciences, and more. https://bldgblog.com/about/